Comments on Mountains and Water: An Introduction to My Book

Thanks for following up. Dave certainly deserves t...

2011-11-26T22:29:58.158-07:00

Thanks for following up. Dave certainly deserves the title of master in my view, though he is certainly not the only one. His contributions to the worldwide practice of bouldering are matched only by Frederic Nicole, making his a particularly valuable presence in the book. To have both Fred and Dave in the volume was an extraordinary opportunity.

In my view, Gill, with his innovations in terms of ideas and technique, transformed bouldering from its more casual origins to a significant independent discipline. His legacy is one every serious boulderer respects to some degree.

Thanks for the good wishes!

my apologies for such abrupt rudeness. while i mig...

2011-11-26T21:52:39.154-07:00

my apologies for such abrupt rudeness. while i might disagree with your assertions (seem like hype), i certainly could have been more tactful (thanksgiving wine went to my head!).

my point was that graham is "a" master, one amongst many contemporary talents, and hard bouldering existed before gill's amazing talents entered the scene (think font v7's in the '50's i believe).

anyways, good luck with the book, and happy holidays.

Of course it doesn't require substantiation. M...

2011-11-25T21:22:03.168-07:00

Of course it doesn't require substantiation. Most anonymous comments seem to avoid any. Why should yours be different?

Also included are personal perspectives, fea...

2011-11-25T19:18:36.110-07:00
Also included are personal perspectives, featuring two lengthy pieces from Dave Graham, the master of the contemporary scene and John Gill, the creator of modern bouldering.

it's silly to call Graham "the" master of the "contemporary scene", more silly than calling Gill "the creator" of bouldering, modern or otherwise.

i think my point doesn't even require substantiation, really, considering the silliness of the original assertion.